Abortion, Feminism and the Environment

 

The Controversy Surrounding Abortion

There are many views on whether abortion is acceptable or not. Many of the arguments are controversial and involve overlapping issues such as ethics, morals, feminism, class and environmental concerns. I myself have hard time agreeing with the choice of abortion but nonetheless do agree that awareness of all arguments of the issue is essential toward understanding all points of view. It is worth exploring each person’s own ethical and moral sense of how they feel about abortion whether it be an extreme conservative view, extreme liberal view, or a more moderate view (Gordon). Gordon explores the moral and legal aspects of abortion in his text.

Focusing on moral and ethical debates Gordon looks at “personhood “ as a means to determine whether a fetus is a human person and if so does it have the legal right to live? I tend to look at this from the “modified standard argument” that the fetus is a human life form rather than from a “standard argument” that addresses the fetus as a human being. It makes more sense to me that a fetus is human life form rather than a human being because it is a form of life. It should be considered life. Women have the amazing ability to give life.

“Personhood”

Intertwined in the text are the different situational circumstances involved in determining if a fetus’s life should be determined by human rights or by a women’s choice. Each group see’s a different morally significant break in the rationalization of the choice to have an abortion. In other words when is it appropriate to morally have an abortion? For example a liberal view would suggest there is a morally significant break at birth. “This means that it is morally permitted to have an abortion before birth and morally prohibited to kill the offspring after birth.” (Gordon). From a moderate viewpoint the ability to suffer is the parameter to determine a morally significant break, which is at about six months. Extreme conservatives believe that the fetus is a person and prohibit abortion justifiable by the assumption that abortion kills human beings. Gordon argues that a fetus is not a person and lacks personhood because it lacks rationality and self-consciousness and therefore lacks “quasi rights” (Gordon). Further explaining, “The fetus is by virtue of his genetic code a human life form but this does not mean that this would be sufficient to grant it legal and moral rights” (Gordon).

Gordon also highlights pregnant women’s right to self-determination, privacy, the right to physical integrity, and the right to live as possible justifications of the choice to abortion. In addition he address’s circumstances from a feminist point of view such as rape, endangerment of the women’s life, serious mentally or physically disabled fetus, and financial and social response that are out of the mothers control and further intrude on her rights as a women. Also important to note in Gordon’s text is the discussion of law and abortion. Does good policy rest on moderate views as he suggests? Or should it be more to the liberal or extreme side? Gordon agrees with Gert who states, “No one thinks that what the law decides about abortion settles the moral issue” (Gordon).

Are you Pro-choice or Pro-forced birth?

In line with Gordon’s evaluation of women’s rights Jessica Valenti argues that abortion is about women’s right to equality. Further expanding the right of women to live, have integrity, and be allowed privacy Valenti references Kathy Pollitt’s book, “Pro: Reclaiming Abortion Rights” stating that women should indeed have the choice to have an abortion in order to make it possible for them to pursue a career and have the same rights as men. We should have the same rights as men; and men should have the same rights as women.  Comparing ourselves to men  has a tendency to divide us rather than make us equal.  Men and women have different qualities that make them unique and that’s what I think should be the focus. A main component of feminism is advocating for equality so how can we be equal if we; men and women are constantly divided by what they can and cannot do? To be clear, Im not suggesting women are equal to men in our society. Valenti further creates inequality by dividing women into “pro-choice groups” and “pro-forced birth” (Valenti) groups playing each against each other further creating animosity instead of sisterhood among women. She makes her argument against pro choicers clear when she says, “The pro-choice movement needs to put the opposition on its heels, and make what some in the “pro-forced birth” movement say what they’re really thinking: that it’s more important for women be mothers than go to college; that the ability to support existing children, to have a job that pays well or to pursue a career path we love are inconsequential realities compared to embracing our “natural” role as perpetually pregnant; that a woman’s ability to incubate a fetus trumps any other contribution to society that she could possibly make” (Valenti).  I do not think women should have to choose between education and a career or motherhood but instead think we should come together to change out-dated policies on a government level that make it difficult to do so and find solutions and create work-family policies to improve a mother’s ability to have both if they choose to. Some women are happy being mothers, some want a career and, some want both. My point is we should work together to achieve equality for men and women (men also face inequality in some instances).

Ecofeminist Perspective on Abortion 

Ronnie Zoe Hawkins presents an ecofeminist perspective on abortion provides the some links between environmental problems, poverty and population growth. Hawkins suggests that we need to have some form of “human population limitation” (Hawkins 691) in order to escape environmental degradation. Hawkins maintains a stance that, “At the present time, recognition of our connectedness with all other life on the planet reinforces the need for abortion” (Hawkins 693). I don’t disagree that there is an issue with population control but also I don’t think this is the sole issue. It is everyone’s responsibility (not just women’s) to ensure a healthy environment.   There are issues contributing to environmental degradation on the private sector such as unregulated corporation waste practices and violations of environmental laws that are already in place that should be taken into account. For example P&G’s “climate commitment” only applies to what are known corporate greenhouse gas accounting as scope I and 2 emissions (Axeirod) but, “But they’re only a fraction of the true impact of P&G’s operations” (Axeirod). See the website for further information on greenhouse gas emission cover-ups. https://www.nrdc.org/experts/josh-axelrod/corporate-honesty-and-climate-change-time-own-and-act.

 

Works Cited

 

Axeirod, Joshua. NDRC.org. 26 February 2019. 5 March 2020 <https://www.nrdc.org/experts/josh-axelrod/corporate-honesty-and-climate-change-time-own-and-act>.

Gordon, John-Stewart. Abortion. 5 March 2020 <https://www.iep.utm.edu/abortion/>.

Hawkins, Ronnie Zoe. “Reproductive Choices: The Ecological Dimension.” Contradictions: Controversies in Feminist Social Ethics. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1993. 690-693.

 

Valenti, Jessica. “Abortion isn’t about the right to privacy. It’s about the right to equality.” The Guardian (2014).

 

Annotated Source: Axeirod, Joshua. NDRC.org

Author Joshua Axelord explores the growing environmental concerns attached to the deliberate dishonesty of big corporations. He details how corporations like P&G use unethical tactics to portray they are not contributing as much greenhouses gases, but they actually are by not including all the information to the public. He agrues there needs to be government involvement that will hold big corporations accountable and lessen their power in todays world with policy change.

980 Replies to “Abortion, Feminism and the Environment”

  1. Magnificent beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend your website, how could i subscribe for a blog web site?
    The account aided me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted Edge Of Fate Expansion this your broadcast provided bright clear concept

  2. Hi there it’s me, I am also visiting this website regularly, this
    web page is really nice and the visitors are truly sharing fastidious thoughts.

  3. عرض سلام و احترام
    پیشنهاد ویژه دارم
    سایت فرمول یکبت
    رو برای قمار آنلاین.
    این پلتفرم امنیت کامل و به درد علاقه‌مندان می‌خوره.

    تجربه مثبتی بود و توصیه می‌شه
    امتحان کنید.
    با احترام.

  4. شب بخیر
    پیشنهاد می‌دم
    سایت تنیس بت
    رو جهت پوکر حرفه ای.
    این سایت عالی ضرایب خوب و برای فرمول
    یک بت عالیه.
    کیفیت سرویس عالی و توصیه دارم ببینید سایت رو.

    با آرزوی موفقیت.

  5. Hey folks friends… You might enjoy something worth
    watchinng clip related to this topic! You might enjoy it and covers relevant stuff.
    I’ve watched quite a few and loved them, and thought you all might
    like it! You won’t regret watching.

    my site xxx

  6. Eh parents, еven thougһ yоur youngster enrolls іn a leading Junior College іn Singapore, lacking а solid math
    foundation, kids miɡht battle with Α Levels verbal ⲣroblems as
    welⅼ as misѕ chances to premium next-level placements lah.

    Tampines Meridian Junior College, fгom a dynamic merger,
    supplies ingenious education іn drama and
    Malay language electives. Innovative centers support varied
    streams, including commerce. Talent development ɑnd
    abroad programs foster management аnd cultural awareness.
    A caring neighborhood motivates empathy ɑnd resilience.
    Trainees are successful in holistic advancement, prepared
    fοr global difficulties.

    Jurong Pioneer Junior College, developed tһrough tһe
    thoughtful merger of Jurong Junior College and Pioneer Junior College, delivers a progressive аnd future-oriented education tһɑt pts a special emphasis ⲟn China preparedness, global company
    acumen, аnd cross-cultural engagement tо prepare students fоr
    thriving in Asia’s dynamic economic landscape. Tһe college’ѕ dual campuses аrе equiplped witһ contemporary,
    versatile facilities including spedcialized commerce simulation гooms, science innovation laboratories, and
    arts ateliers, aⅼl designed to promote practical skills, imaginative thinking, аnd interdisciplinary learning.
    Enhancing academic programs ɑгe matched by
    worldwide cooperations, ѕuch as joint projects witһ Chinese universities аnd cultural immersion journeys, ѡhich improve trainees’ linguistic proficiency
    аnd international outlook. А supportive ɑnd inclusive community atmosphere encourages durability аnd management development tһrough
    a wide variety of ⅽo-curricular activities, fгom entrepreneurship clubѕ to sports ɡroups
    that promote team effort аnd determination. Graduates оf Jurong Pioneer Junior College ɑrе exceptionally ԝell-prepared for competitive careers, embodying tһe worths of care, continuous enhancement, ɑnd development thаt define thе institution’ѕ forward-ⅼooking values.

    Οh mаn, no matter thougһ school proves һigh-еnd,
    maths acts lіke the critical topic іn developing poise ѡith numЬers.

    Alas, primary math teaches real-woгld implementations
    including financial planning, tһuѕ guarantee уour youngster getѕ that right
    beցinning young.

    Listen ᥙp, steady pom pі pi, maths is ρart from tһe top subjects аt Junior College, building groundwork to A-Level calculus.

    Alas, lacking strong math ɑt Junior College, no matter tоp institution children might stumble іn һigh school equations, tһuѕ
    develop tһis now leh.

    Bе kiasu and track progress; consistent improvemenmt leads tο Α-level wins.

    Ꭺpart fгom establishment resources, concentrate ᴡith mathematics
    tⲟ ѕtop typical pitfalls ⅼike inattentive
    errors аt assessments.
    Mums аnd Dads, competitive approach οn lah, strong
    primary math guides іn improved science understanding ɑnd construction aspirations.

    Alsо visit mʏ web ρage secondary math tuition assignment

  7. Hi there everyone! I recently saw a really cool highlight on this platform…
    Very well maee Plus, it’s wel worth a look.
    There’s so much interesting content there, and thought some of you would like it.
    Give it a lolok and see.

    Here is my web-site; xxx

  8. Simply wish to say your article is as surprising. The clearness for your put up is just excellent and that i can think
    you are a professional in this subject. Fine along with
    your permission let me to seize your RSS feed to stay up to date with coming near near post.
    Thank you a million and please continue the gratifying work.

  9. The other day, while I was at work, my cousin stole my iPad and tested to see if it can survive a 40 foot drop,
    just so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPad is now broken and she has 83
    views. I know this is completely off topic but I had to share it with someone!

  10. Hello my family member! I want to say that this post is awesome, great written and come with
    almost all important infos. I would like to see extra
    posts like this .

  11. Hey all community… You might enjoy an amazing footage that ties in nicely…
    Fuun and enjoyable Plus, it’s a great choice.
    There’s so much interesting content there,
    and figured it’s relevant for readers! Feel free to ccheck it out and
    comment.

    My web-site; xxx

  12. Woah! I’m really loving the template/theme of this blog.
    It’s simple, yet effective. A lot of times it’s very hard to get that “perfect balance” between superb
    usability and visual appeal. I must say that you’ve done
    a amazing job with this. Additionally, the blog loads very quick for me on Firefox.

    Outstanding Blog!

  13. درود فراوان
    به نظرم امتحان کنید
    سایت کازینو برتر
    رو جهت تنیس بت.
    این اپ کاربردی امنیت بالایی داره و برای کرش گیم عالیه.

    ضرایبش بالاست و جذاب برای امتحانه.

    ارادتمند فاطمه.

  14. Hey all community. Check out a fun and engaging
    content on this platform! Could be interesting for anyone reading this Plus, it’s a great choice.
    I’ve watched quite a few annd loved them, and thought youu all might like
    it! Let me know your thoughts.

    My blog – porn

  15. درود و سلام
    پیشنهاد می‌کنم سایت
    سایت دنیای هات بت
    رو برای پوکر.
    این پلتفرم عالی ضرایب خوب و برای کاربران
    جدید مناسبه.
    پشتیبانی 24/7 و جذاب برای امتحانه.

    با احترام.

  16. Hello there! This article couldn’t be written much better!

    Going through this post reminds me of my previous roommate!
    He constantly kept preaching about this. I most certainly will forward this information to him.
    Fairly certain he will have a good read. Many thanks
    for sharing!

  17. درود و احترام امیر
    به نظرم امتحان کنید
    سایت تخته نرد آنلاین
    رو برای فرمول یک.
    این سرویس معتبر پشتیبانی سریع و
    برای کاربران ایرانی مناسبه.

    به نظرم بهترینه و به نظرم ارزش داره.

    تشکر ویژه.

  18. Hello folks here! I found a fun and engaging
    clip that might intedest you. Worth your time and covers popular topics.

    I’ve watched quite a few and loved them, and you mightt fknd it
    entertaining! Feel free to check it out and comment!

    my homepage … porn tube

  19. درود و احترام امیر
    توصیه دارم ببینید
    سایت پاسور هات
    رو جهت بلک جک.
    این سایت محبوب امنیت بالا و برای حرفه‌ای‌ها مناسبه.

    تجربه خوبی داشتم و پیشنهاد می‌کنم تست کنید.

    پیروز باشید زهرا.

  20. درود و سلام
    پیشنهاد ویژه
    سایت تهران کازینو
    رو در زمینه تنیس.
    این سایت امنیت بالایی داره و برای والیبال شرطی عالیه.

    برای ایرانی‌ها عالیه و پیشنهاد می‌دم ثبت نام کنید.

    موفق باشید حسین.

Leave a Reply to porn Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *